Why can’t I find a DNA match in Ireland?

Wondering why you don't have an Irish DNA match yet? Here's why fewer people test in Ireland and how to track down your ancestors anyway.

Now Reading:

Why can’t I find a DNA match in Ireland?

Céad Míle Fáilte, and you are very welcome to this week’s Letter from Ireland. The mornings are getting darker here in Cork, with October just upon us. How are things in your part of the world today?

I have a cup of Barry’s tea by my side as I write, so I do hope you’ll join me with a cup of whatever you fancy yourself.

Last Sunday I asked whether you knew what became of the relatives who stayed behind in Ireland after your family left. The replies have been varied and wonderful, and are still coming in. But over in the Green Room, a side conversation started up about using DNA to help figure out if you still have relatives in Ireland, and it has been running all through the week.

Marc, who lives in the United States, put the point across better than I can. “I don’t know of any relatives remaining in Ireland, although there may be some,” he wrote. “Most of my Irish folk emigrated to Scotland, and I have many relatives still in Scotland. Perhaps I’ll get an Irish DNA match, but have not gotten any Irish leads during the decades that I’ve been looking at DNA matches. Is DNA testing very popular in Ireland?”

DNA testing certainly seems less common here than where you are, Marc, and your question is one I hear on a regular basis. Many of our readers open their DNA match lists and find potential cousins all around the world, but struggle to find someone living in Ireland itself.

What the Numbers Actually Tell Us

Back in 2018 I wrote a letter here called “A Journey into Irish DNA”, and in it I commented on this – how few people on the island of Ireland seemed to have taken a DNA test for ancestry purposes. I wanted to see what had changed in the meantime, so I went looking for the figures this week.

In the United States, a YouGov survey last year found that about one in five adults had taken a home DNA test. A British survey the year before found that about one in ten adults had taken one. I could not find a reliable equivalent for Ireland. The DNA testing companies have millions of people in their databases, but that does not tell us how many of them live here in Ireland.

Clans of Ireland has also highlighted limited participation by Irish residents in Y-DNA surname projects. These projects, they wrote, attracted people from many countries, “but they held little interest for the Irish who were still resident in Ireland.” They have encouraged more people living here to take part, so that their results can provide a point of comparison for descendants abroad, particularly where a family’s roots in one area are well documented.

Why People in Ireland May See Less Reason to Test

I suspect part of the answer comes down to why people test in the first place. For most of our readers abroad, somebody left Ireland, the communications back and forward thinned out over a few generations until one or both sides lost contact or interest.

For many Irish residents with longstanding roots in Ireland, that particular loss can be felt less keenly. The family graves are in the local churchyard, the old homeplace is down the road, and there is usually an aunt who can tell you who married whom over the past three generations. You might not know much about your great-great-grandparents, but you may feel you already know where you come from. We often feel that we have more than enough cousins to deal with already!

Carina and I are a good example. I have taken an autosomal test with Ancestry and a Y-DNA test with FamilyTreeDNA, but only after I started writing this Letter in 2013. Carina has taken an autosomal test with MyHeritage. Neither of us took the tests to discover where we came from, or to connect with cousins. We did it out of an interest in genealogy, and I think that is true of a good many people who have tested here in Ireland.

There may be other reasons why people in Ireland are slow to take a DNA test. Some people are uncomfortable about sending a DNA sample to a commercial company, or wonder who might have access to their information. When people do test, the reason can be deeply personal. Adopted people, including people born in Mother and Baby Homes, have used DNA to help find birth relatives when the records could not give them the answers. For some families, those discoveries have been life changing.

So, I would be careful about putting everyone here into the same category. People test for all sorts of reasons. But someone who knows where their family has lived for generations may need a different reason from someone who has spent years trying to find that place.

How to Improve Your Chances of an Irish DNA Match

So, back to Marc’s original point and question. You do not need a match living in Ireland to discover where your Irish family came from. A cousin in America, Australia or Britain who descends from the same Irish ancestors may have a family letter, an old certificate, or a better researched branch of the tree that names the place you are looking for. The information may have survived in their branch even if it was lost in yours.

Before buying another test, I would take a look again at the matches you already have. Have you linked your results to a family tree? Can you identify a few matches connected to the same Irish branch? Look at their trees and shared matches, and see whether the same places keep appearing. Those are clues to follow up in the records.

The autosomal test most of us have taken (the typical Ancestry.com DNA test) looks across both sides of your family. It can find quite distant cousins, but as the relationship gets further away, there is less chance that you have both inherited enough of the same DNA to show as a match. Two people can be genuine distant cousins and have no detectable match at all. So, if you have an older relative on the relevant side of the family who would like to test, it can help. A parent, aunt or uncle may carry DNA from your shared ancestors that you did not inherit.

Then there is Y-DNA. This follows the line from father to son, and often follows the surname through generations beyond the surviving paper records. If the Irish branch you are researching is your direct father-to-son line, this is an avenue worth exploring. If you are a woman, or a man researching a different branch, you would need a male relative descended from the ancestor you are investigating through an unbroken father-to-son line. Having the right surname alone is not enough.

FamilyTreeDNA offers these tests, and surname projects and the Ireland yDNA Project can help you make sense of the results. It is worth asking a project administrator for advice before choosing a test. A close match to men whose paternal families have documented roots around one parish may give you a useful pointer for further research. You can also widen your search across databases. GEDmatch accepts DNA uploads from other testing companies, and FamilyTreeDNA accepts certain compatible files. Do check the current requirements and privacy choices before uploading anywhere.

And this goes back to last week’s letter. If you have found a family line that stayed in Ireland, or even a strong possibility of one, consider offering to pay for a willing cousin here in Ireland to test. Explain what you hope to learn and agree who will manage the results. One carefully chosen test, alongside the records, may help you make sense of a whole group of matches.

Back to Where We Started

Is DNA testing popular in Ireland? In my experience, it seems less common here than in America, although reliable Irish figures remain hard to find. But I would not let the absence of a match living here discourage you. Remember that a cousin who helps you find your Irish homeplace could be living anywhere in the world.

So here is the question I would like to share with you this week: Have you ever had a DNA match with someone living in Ireland today, and how did it come about? Or have you ever asked a cousin in Ireland to take a test?

Do let me know in the comments section below.

Thank you for reading and sharing this letter.

Slán for now,

Mike

Plus Member Comments

Only Plus Members can comment - Join Now

If you already have an account - Sign In Here.